On Nov. 9, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit ruled that parts of California’s corporate climate disclosure laws likely violate the First Amendment, reversing in part a lower court’s denial of a preliminary injunction business groups had sought.
The appeals court upheld the district court’s refusal to block Scope 1 and Scope 2 emissions reporting requirements under SB 253 but reversed its decision concerning Scope 3 emissions disclosures and climate-related financial risk reporting under SB 261.
SB 253 requires certain companies doing business in California to report direct and indirect greenhouse gas emissions associated with their businesses. Scope 1 emissions come from sources a company owns or controls, Scope 2 emissions result from the generation of purchased electricity and other energy, and Scope 3 emissions come from other activities throughout the company’s supply chain and broader value chain.
The two laws, enacted in 2023, established different reporting requirements:
- SB 253 requires U.S.-based companies doing business in California with annual revenues exceeding $1 billion to disclose greenhouse gas emissions, including emissions from their operations, purchased energy, and value chains.
- SB 261 requires companies doing business in California with annual revenues exceeding $500 million to publish biennial reports on climate-related financial risks and measures taken to address them.
California is the only state with a broad corporate greenhouse gas emissions disclosure law requiring qualifying companies to report emissions regardless of where they are headquartered. Although other states have statutory greenhouse gas reporting requirements, those programs generally focus on specific industries, facilities, or sources.
The three-judge panel found that Scope 1 and Scope 2 disclosures constitute commercial speech and satisfy intermediate scrutiny under the First Amendment. It determined that Scope 3 disclosures and SB 261 compel noncommercial speech, making them subject to strict scrutiny, which the requirements failed to satisfy.
The ruling was issued one day before California’s Nov. 10 deadline for initial Scope 1 and Scope 2 emissions reports, which remains in effect.
The decision distinguishes between emissions disclosures tied to a company’s own operations and broader reporting requirements involving its supply chain and assessments of future climate-related financial risks. The court found that the latter requirements likely violate the First Amendment, potentially limiting California’s ability to mandate those disclosures.
The case now returns to the district court to determine whether SB 253’s Scope 3 provisions can be separated from the rest of the law. The appellate ruling does not constitute a final judgment on the constitutional challenge, but its findings support preliminary injunctive relief against Scope 3 reporting and SB 261.
Several business associations, including the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, challenged the laws on First Amendment grounds. A U.S. district court denied their request for a preliminary injunction, finding that the reporting requirements were unlikely to violate the Constitution.
The Ninth Circuit temporarily blocked enforcement of SB 261 in November 2025 while the appeal was pending but declined to block SB 253 at that time.
Ballotpedia tracks support for and opposition to the environmental, social, and corporate governance (ESG) investing movement. To learn more about arguments for, against, and about ESG, click here. For more information on reform proposals related to ESG policy, click here.
This article was originally published by Ballotpedia and is republished under its Creative Commons terms, unedited.