(The Center Square) – Lawmakers and policy experts disagreed over how to address Social Security’s looming financial shortfall, with proposals ranging from higher taxes on wealthy Americans to restructuring the program and broader federal spending cuts.
Social Security’s retirement fund is projected to run out of reserves in 2032, at which point incoming revenue would cover only about 78% of promised benefits, according to the program’s trustees’ report.
Established in 1935 under President Franklin D. Roosevelt, Social Security is funded primarily through payroll taxes paid by workers and employers. For decades, the program collected more money than it needed to pay benefits.
Those surpluses were invested in Treasury bonds, allowing the Treasury Department to use the money for other parts of the federal budget.
But in 2010, Social Security began paying out more in benefits and other expenses than it collected in taxes. An aging population and declining ratio of workers to retirees have widened the gap, forcing the program to redeem its Treasury bonds to cover the shortfall. With those reserves projected to run out, lawmakers face difficult decisions about how to preserve the program for future generations.
Senate Budget Committee Chairman Ron Johnson, R-Wis., called Wednesday for legislation to prevent Social Security benefit reductions, arguing that the program’s financial problems should be addressed as part of broader efforts to reduce federal debt and deficits.
He opposed raising the annual earnings cap on Social Security payroll taxes, arguing that doing so would be unfair to higher-income taxpayers and could discourage spending and investment.
Under current law, workers pay Social Security taxes at a flat rate of 6.2% on their first $184,500 in annual wages, with employers contributing an equal amount. Higher earners therefore contribute more to the program in dollar terms, but Social Security’s benefit formula generally replaces a smaller percentage of their previous earnings in retirement.
Johnson described Social Security as a “legal Ponzi scheme.”
“People often say, ‘Don’t touch Social Security; that’s my money.’ Actually, it’s not,” Johnson said. “Your money was spent to pay current beneficiaries or fund other government programs as soon as it was collected from your paycheck.”
Jeff Merkley, D-Ore., defended Social Security as a combination of savings and insurance, arguing that its structure is intended to provide greater relative support to lower-income retirees.
He also defended the legal requirement that Social Security’s reserves be invested in U.S. government securities, saying it protected the program from the risk of major stock market losses.
“If you invest it in bonds, well, that’s a guaranteed and the safest return, and you don’t run the risk of a massive collapse of the stock market,” Merkley said.
Merkley advocated raising the payroll tax earnings cap and requiring wealthy Americans to pay Social Security taxes on investment income, noting that some wealthy individuals earn little or no income from wages.
He argued that wealthy Americans should contribute more to the program, while Johnson pointed to the large share of federal income taxes already paid by higher earners.
Veronique de Rugy, a senior research fellow at George Mason University’s Mercatus Center, disagreed with the notion that eliminating the payroll tax cap would solve Social Security’s financial problems.
“Eliminating the payroll tax cap would close at most about half of the long-term shortfall, while pushing top marginal rates on our most productive professionals, including physicians, which we are already short of, past 60% in some states,” de Rugy said.
She also argued that changes to Social Security’s benefit structure are necessary to address the program’s long-term financial problems.
“Congress should act gradually and predictably, protect the most vulnerable, give workers time to adjust, slow the built-in growth of benefits and align retirement age with longevity,” she said.
De Rugy also warned against covering Social Security’s shortfall with general federal revenue, arguing that doing so would shift the financial burden to the rest of the federal budget rather than eliminate it.
Jason Fichtner, executive director of the LIMRA Retirement Income Institute, criticized Social Security’s trust fund structure, calling it “an accounting gimmick.”
“The trust fund should not be mistaken for a pile of marketable savings set aside for future retirees. It is, in practical budget terms, an intergovernmental accounting mechanism,” Fichtner said, adding that it can “obscure the real fiscal choices facing Congress.”
Fichtner also argued that Social Security’s financial problems reflect a broader imbalance between the federal government’s spending commitments and the money it raises to pay for them.
Kathryn Anne Edwards, a labor economist and senior fellow at the National Academy of Social Insurance, proposed several approaches to strengthening Social Security, including eliminating the payroll tax cap, raising tax rates and using revenue from corporate income and capital gains taxes to help fund benefits.
During an exchange with Johnson, the chairman repeatedly pressed Edwards to identify the maximum tax rate she believed wealthy Americans should pay, but she declined to name a figure. Instead, Edwards argued that the greater problem was the tax breaks available to wealthy taxpayers.
“The real problem isn’t the marginal rates; it’s the number of coupons that wealthy families are able to claim,” Edwards said, arguing that those tax breaks have allowed wealthy Americans to reduce the share of their income they pay in taxes.
Beyond raising revenue, Edwards advocated investing in workers through labor law reforms and greater access to childcare, which she argued could increase workforce participation and strengthen Social Security’s finances. She also called for expanding Social Security to include paid family and medical leave.
“Across party lines, Americans have resoundingly said they do not want benefit cuts, even if that means paying higher taxes themselves,” Edwards said.
This article was originally published by The Center Square and is republished under its open-access guidelines.
