The Rightist

News, Conservative opinion, and a good-natured jab at the left

?Leftist of the DayWho is it today? →

Maricopa County election officials issue dueling canvasses

(The Center Square) – In a highly unusual move, the Maricopa County recorder and Board of Supervisors put out separate recaps of the midterm elections in Arizona’s most populous county on Wednesday.

The traditional post-vote canvass, which is traditionally released by the Board of Supervisors, had company from Recorder Justin Heap, who broke down early voting in the county to reporters in the morning in Phoenix.

In that press conference, Heap told media members that the 2026 midterms saw 83.4% of voters cast their ballots before Election Day, with 1,300,777 of the county’s 1,559,706 votes coming through some form of early voting.

Additionally, 5,909 ballots were cast by military and overseas voters, in addition to 692 by the county’s Special Elections Board (including 239 large-print ballots and 30 braille ballots for blind voters) and 102,514 early ballots that were dropped off at a polling station or vote center using the county’s “ID Verified” program, according to Heap.

Heap, who has been in frequent disagreement with the county’s board, said his reasoning behind releasing a second canvass of the election stemmed from that acrimonious relationship between the two camps.

“We thought it was important to do that separately this time and to have our own meeting,” Heap said. “And the reason for doing so is it is simply this: The recorder’s appearance at the canvas is merely a courtesy done for the board.

“Unfortunately, because after almost a year and a half of litigation and issues between us and the board, the board continues to use every voluntary appearance by my office in good faith at a public meeting as an opportunity for them to make accusations or score political partisan points at these meetings, I don’t think that’s productive or helpful for instilling confidence in the election,” he added.

In his press conference, Heap praised the Recorder’s Office for its ability to handle what he said was double the number of early votes, compared with the last midterm election in 2022.

“I do also take that as a mark of some of the confidence that I’ve managed to instill in the public that many voters who might have waited until Election Day were more confident coming in and voting early in person because it was under my office,” Heap said.

Heap also cited his office’s ability to churn through the 194,147 “late earlies,” or early ballots that were dropped off on Election Day, in a single day (compared with three-to-five days in previous elections) and its ability to fulfill thousands of ballot curing requests before the Nov. 8 deadline as proof that his team thrived in the face of adversity in 2026.

“We brought in our workers, and we began our first shift at 2 a.m. the day after elections. And we were able to complete all the signature verification on all the remaining ballots by 1 p.m. the day following elections, to get those handed over, which is a new record,” Heap said.

“And we did it largely by improving both our operations, but we also showed that you can do it faster and actually increase security and transparency on the ballots that come through,” he added.

Three hours after Heap stepped out from behind his lectern at the Maricopa County Tabulation Center, the county’s five-person board knocked out its traditional election canvass.

The board’s canvass took place inside the board’s clamshell auditorium on the opposite side of the railroad tracks from the concrete warehouse where Heap spoke, though the latter meeting took a different tone than the one Heap put on.

Kate Brophy McGee, chair of the Maricopa County Board of Supervisors, discusses early canvassing results during a meeting in Phoenix, Nov. 18, 2026. Photo: Christopher Boan / The Center Square

At the start of Wednesday’s canvass, Board Chair Kate Brophy McGee read into record a letter she sent to Recorder Heap on Nov. 10, since he did not attend the afternoon’s meeting.

The letter asked Heap how many ballots were rejected by his office over things like bad signatures, no signatures whatsoever or for being returned late, in addition to queries about how those amounts compare to the 2022 midterms.

“Mr. Recorder, we have the name plate in front of your chair. You are welcome to join us,” Brophy McGee said.

During his comments to the five-member board, Maricopa County Elections Chair Scott Jarrett laid out the highlights of the 4,000-page, precinct-level report that his department compiled on this year’s midterms.

Most of Jarrett’s findings matched those released by Heap’s office, with minor discrepancies, such as the number provisional ballots that were accepted, which his office counted at 1,029, compared to the 1,026 figure that the Recorder stated.

The difference stemmed from three voters not returning their ballot envelopes when they were given a provisional ballot, Jarrett said, meaning their votes were automatically disqualified.

Above all, Jarrett told the board members that this year’s elections ran smoothly, thanks to the more than 3,500 temporary workers that answered the call.

“We have just a wonderful community that steps up to support elections and serve Maricopa County voters every single time we have these big elections,” Jarrett said.

“And I like to think of the poll workers as really the base of Maricopa County. They’re the ones that are serving those voters in our in-person facilities, and they have to encourage the voters, learn all the different complex processes of serving a voter and being that base. But I like to think of our electoral workers as the heart of the election,” he added.

Superintendent Steve Gallardo pressed Jarrett about what requirements were not met by the more than 2,021 voters that Heap’s office said were not eligible to vote.

“It’s very disturbing that Mr. Heap is not here, again, just showing that he’s not really taking his job seriously, Madam Chair,” Gallardo said. “Because that would be one question that I know the folks here, especially in the audience and outside that are listening, would really want to know, is exactly why these ballots or these registered voters that, for whatever reason, were removed from the roll, were suspended by Mr. Heap.”

The Maricopa County Board of Superivsors discusses election cavasing results during its meeting in Phoenix, Nov. 18, 2026. Photo: Christopher Boan / The Center Square

When it came to voter turnout, Jarrett said the 2026 midterms finished at 60.2%, down slightly from the 64% of voters that turned out four years ago. Still, he said this year’s elections finished above the county’s historical turnout rate over the last three decades (55.4%).

Jarrett said that 138 of the county’s 254 Election Day locations had zero wait time during the prime, post-work hours from 5-7 p.m. this year, with voters having plenty of voting location options to choose from if there was a line at their chosen polling place.

“In every one of those cases, there was a nearby location that was available for voters, usually within one to two to three miles from that vote center that had a wait time that was less than 10 minutes away,” Jarrett said. “And we used our social media accounts as well as our website to be able to advertise those to voters, so that they knew that there were other options for them.”

Assistant County Manager Zach Schira told board members that the county’s election-related advertising campaigns had punched well above their weight class, with more than 15 million views on an advertising budget of less than $500,000.

“That was a tremendous, tremendous rate from our community members,” Schira said. “So I want to thank the team, and I want to thank those who worked with us.”

Schira said the lone district in the state Legislature that hasn’t been decided is Arizona House District 27, where two GOP candidates (Lisa Fink and Tony Romero) are currently separated by 313 votes (or 0.29%), behind Democrat Deborah Howard, who got 37.3% in this year’s election, with two people from each district advancing to the legislature.

Schira said Arizona’s laws require automatic recounts when the margin is 0.5% or less, with the County Elections Department conducting the recount next week.

“On Monday, after the secretary of state canvasses the results for the election, we will begin the recount,” Schira said. “And we plan to take that recount right through Thanksgiving week, we will be working Thanksgiving Day, a half day that day, to count these ballots and get these recount results out as quickly as possible.”

Board Vice Chair Debbie Lesko succinctly summed up her thoughts on the midterms at the tail end of the board meeting on Wednesday evening. 

“As a Republican, I didn’t like the results of the election. election, but I do trust that the process went very well, and I am confident in the canvass election results,” Lesko said. 

This article was originally published by The Center Square and is republished under its open-access guidelines.