The Rightist

News, Conservative opinion, and a good-natured jab at the left

?Leftist of the DayWho is it today? →

Lifetime misunderstanding leads former Erie Democratic leader to self-deport

(The Center Square) — Wrongly believing himself a legal U.S. citizen for seven decades, a prominent former Democratic leader and attorney from Erie, Pennsylvania, voluntarily deported himself to Canada earlier this month.

First reported by the Erie Times-News, Ian Murray, who moved to the city in 1956 and lived there until his retirement as a defense attorney in 2022, left for Nova Scotia on Nov. 12 after learning that his Canadian-born mother didn’t meet residency requirements to qualify him as an American citizen after he was born in 1951.

During this time, he maintained government identification, served on Erie City Council, chaired the Erie Democratic Party, and served as the Pennsylvania voice in the Democratic National Committee. After his retirement, he moved to Maine.

Federal immigration law dating back to 1940, the Nationality Act, led the Canadian-born Murray to believe he was a U.S. citizen because of his mother’s dual citizenship. She fell short of the 10-year residency requirement for dual citizenship, however, after spending four years pursuing a degree in Toronto. Murray didn’t know she never qualified until he applied for a passport last year.

The Center Square was unable to contact Murray to independently confirm the report’s details.

The 1940 law, which was absorbed into the Immigration and Nationality Act of 1952, included a carve-out for violators who unknowingly claimed false citizenship. A 2019 update from U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services says the federal government no longer considers intent a mitigating factor in determining punishment for falsification allegations.

The Department of State declined to comment to The Center Square on Wednesday regarding how many deportation cases stem from similar circumstances.

The Center Square was unable to find a government database that tracks the number of people deported for unknowingly claiming false citizenship. Voluntary deportation, rather than court-ordered removal, avoids a 10-year re-entry ban and a civil penalty that could hit nearly $10,000, according to the Immigrant Legal Resource Center.  

This article was originally published by The Center Square and is republished under its open-access guidelines.