The Rightist

News, Conservative opinion, and a good-natured jab at the left

?Leftist of the DayWho is it today? →

DHS is winning the border and losing the argument about it

The Department of Homeland Security has done the hard thing. It shut the front door, and the fiscal year that just ended was the quietest at the southern border in the agency’s history. It is now spending its energy on the easy thing: calling a think tank names. The fight over whether the government is deporting a million people a year misses the number that actually changed the country, and conservatives should be the first to say so.

The spat

On October 21 the Migration Policy Institute (MPI) published a fact sheet built on DHS’s own records, pried loose under the Freedom of Information Act. It counts about 980,000 deportations from January 20, 2025 through July 31, 2026. That pace works out to roughly 660,000 in fiscal 2026, 26 percent above the Biden years but well short of the million a year the administration promised.

The response was swift. A White House spokesperson told NewsNation it was a “fake news report from a leftist group.” DHS posted the same verdict in capital letters. The White House’s own tally, in a release dated October 20, is nearly 1.2 million deported or removed and more than 3 million gone altogether.

Give the critics their due

Take MPI seriously. Its author, Marc Rosenblum, used to run the DHS statistics office. And the report says something the Right should not wave away: DHS has not published a detailed monthly enforcement report since January 2025. When a government stops publishing its numbers, outsiders fill the gap, and the government forfeits the right to complain about their arithmetic.

MPI also notes that only 20 percent of those deported had a criminal conviction, and that among people here two years or more, 71 percent had none. That is true. It is also beside the point. Being here illegally is the violation. A country that removes only the convicted has decided it has no border, just a parole board.

The number that matters

Now look at what both sides are counting. Deportations are the back door. The front door is the one that mattered, and it is as close to shut as it has ever been. DHS’s preliminary figures for fiscal 2026: 98,708 Border Patrol apprehensions on the southwest border, a 95 percent drop from the Biden era; 379,243 encounters nationwide, the lowest the agency has ever recorded; and 17 straight months with zero releases into the country. The Biden administration’s single busiest month, 249,740 apprehensions, was two and a half times this entire year.

Every person not released at the border is a deportation that never has to happen, a court date that never clogs the docket, and a shelter bed a city never bills to Washington. MPI’s own figures make the point for us: 69 percent of the deportations it counted were people caught at the border, not in the interior. Deterrence is the whole game. A million a year was always a campaign yardstick. “Nobody gets in” is the policy, and it is working.

Print the receipts

This is precisely why the fake-news deflection is the wrong move. The Right spent four years demanding that the government count things honestly, from the got-aways nobody would tally to the 16,070 ICE detainers New York refused to honor. DHS was right to publish that one. It cannot ask for receipts from Albany and stop printing its own. If the department believes its 3 million figure, the fix is a monthly table and the integrity to own any shortcomings, not ad hominem attacks via X.

The data tells the administration’s story without any help. Crossings are at a record low. Releases are zero. Border deaths are down nearly 80 percent. Secretary Mullin put it in three words: “strong enforcement works.” He is right. Conservatives should stop defending a number that was never the point and start defending the one that was. Then show the math.

Sources